“One day our descendants will think it incredible that we paid so much attention to things like the amount of melanin in our skin or the shape of our eyes or our gender instead of the unique identities of each of us as complex human beings.” ~Franklin Thomas
I grew up in a rather small, rather white town in Upstate New York. One of those towns where everyone knew their neighbors business. You saw your teachers in the grocery store (you guys, teachers have lives outside of school!) and So and So’s mom would tell your mom if she saw you out past 11. That kind of town. Given the demographics it should come as no surprise that I was the odd girl out. I always hoped no one would notice but of course they did. Those moments when my peers would point out the color of my skin as if to remind me. Thanks, friends, for keeping me in check. It was the nothing that was often something and it made me feel uncomfortable in my own skin. I oscillated between groups; one who thought I was too black and the others who thought I wasn’t black enough. 15 is hard enough. One need not make it worse.
College was easier and even my first jobs were a breeze. I lived in DC and let’s gloss over the fact that I ended up in DC months before my classmates so that I could be in a “special” summer program for the brown and black students. It was chocolate city! Later my coworkers and I were our little melting pot striving for progressive politics and policies across the country. And then I moved back to Albany.
There’s something to be said for being the Only One. Not in a precious way but I often observed and continue to notice three years later that I am often the only one who looks like me in the room. I am a black, female working in politics. There aren’t that many of me hanging out in Upstate NY but, you know, I take it in stride. In the beginning it was a shock and as I would peer around a room during a fundraiser I’d get a jolt when I realized that there were no other black people there. Let alone women. But that jolt forced me to stand up straighter and taller and to fix my hair and make sure my makeup wasn’t running. I would check my shoes and fix the collar on my shirt because in someone’s eyes I was there to represent my people. Whomever those people might be.
Here’s the thing; I own a mirror and every single morning I wake up and look in that mirror. I put on my make up and wash off the residue on my hands from my foundation which leaves a brown smudge on a formerly pristine towel. I know what color I am. Most black people, brown people, whatever color people realize their color and don’t need to be reminded of such. And we certainly need not be told that we are not doing enough to prove to the masses that we are in fact whatever color we are.
Which brings me to this morning and Maureen Dowd and the New York Times. And if you looked up “liberal elitism” in the dictionary – scratch that – in Urban Dictionary there would be the New York Times logo. The New York Times which is here to show us poor colored folks that if we did things differently then maybe we would be better at being a person of color. I thank them for that. When someone pointed out Dowd’s opinion piece this morning I was hurt and in a second I was hurled back to a feeling one where no matter what I do and how hard I try in someone’s eyes I would not be good enough. There would always be someone to say that I wasn’t being black in the proper way. I had an entire adolescence full of teenagers who presented me with the same argument. So what on Earth was I thinking when I thought that adults could look past such trivial matters. Furthermore she was, in part, correct. The Shirley Sherrod situation – Sherrodgate – was handled poorly on all sides. But instead of calling out Tom Vilsack – who apparently makes an excellent white guy from Iowa - she calls out the President. Because Barack Obama isn’t aware enough of his blackness. In fact, according to Ms. Dowd, he kind of sucks at being black and he should probably have a Czar of Blackness in his inner-circle. You know, someone who plays Jay-Z on repeat in the Oval Office. That that was Maureen Dowd’s takeaway on a situation that was a shit show from jump street makes me embarrassed for her and the paper she writes for.
After reading her piece, I went to a fundraiser in Saratoga. There I stood in a room full of people and was the youngest person there and also the darkest. I hadn’t had a wave of self-consciousness like that in ages. Were they looking at me? When they saw me did they only see race? Did they wonder why I was there and who I knew or why I would be invited? Was I good enough to be there?
Instead of enjoying myself and working as I was supposed to do, I have gone through the entire day overly aware of myself. I’ve spent all of today questioning myself and whether I am good enough for certain people. It’s 2010 and I am walking on eggshells because of Maureen fucking Dowd. Overly worried about my race. Like high school; politics is bad enough. One need not make it worse. And yet there are people in the world and there will always be people in the world who do.






18 Comments
I don’t have anything smart to say here, but I wanted to comment just to say that this is a really good post. It is.
Yeah – because people can’t just be idiot – regardless of sex/race/age.
I think ‘the administration’ blew it big. The men/women/and each and every race. WTF people? We only consider the ABBREVIATED-CLIFF-NOTES version of something … presented by people with a CLEAR AGENDA … and jump to action?!?
Seriously – throughout this all, you know how has the MOST CLASS? Shirley – and the farmer she ended up helping. That’s who I want leading this country.
sorry – yours was excellent.
I can totally relate. I’m not in political circles but I am often the only black person – male of female in the room. My circle is the art world where I have to overcome being not only a woman artist, but a black artist and all of the assumptions around that (as far as if my work ‘represents’ these stereotypes properly). I often fall short in the eyes of others because I don’t fit into their expectations of what they think I ‘should’ be.
But – you know what? After a day like the one you just described, you have to brush yourself off and simply say, “To hell with it! Imma be ME!” and live your life unapologetically. This isn’t to say that you won’t have days like today or feel self conscious at times but the reality is – you are breaking down walls and making strides as a pioneer everyday simply by being YOU. (Hope that remark doesn’t add pressure. It was mean to comfort and encourage…)
You just don’t understand how hard we white people have it, deciding how black people should behave. Have some sympathy!
No, joking. Sometimes what I think would be best would be for white people to shut up about race and just listen. For a little while, maybe 100 years or so.
EXCELLENT POST!
I came in to say exactly what kristine said. Heather, I am about 12 years older that you and am a black, female scientist, living in Minneapolis. I am always the only one who looks like me in the room and often the entire building.
Be yourself. All you can be is a single point of data in any experience. If people like Maureen Dowd understood that there is no one way to be black (and this includes black people) these false racial constructs can begin to fall away.
There are also people in the world, a lot of us, who genuinely don’t care about the color of your skin. It’s up to you to decide who/what defines you. Maureen Dowd doesn’t have any power over you, unless you give it to her.
It’s appalling, that article. I couldn’t believe it when you directed it our way.
They should have changed the title to “White Lady says Black President isn’t Black Enough.”
Perhaps then they would have seen the ridiculousness in that piece?
I can’t imagine why Ms. Dowd would think the cabinet would be sensitive about race…
Very well said. There was something in Maureen Dowd’s comments that made me itchy and I couldn’t put my finger on it. You nailed it.
” I have gone through the entire day overly aware of myself.”
I hate this. I hate this because I know that it’s true and I’m not sure how to help make it untrue. Not just for you, but for other people who are not middle class white people. Pretending you don’t or shouldn’t feel that way doesn’t help, but acknowledging you do – reminding you that you are black and asking you to be the token black female – doesn’t seem like it would help make you less aware of it either.
I wish someone could show me what the middle ground was.
Wait a minute…you’re black?
MoDo makes me mad. I stopped reading her years ago. I don’t want to read someone who is supposed to be “on my side” but who keeps getting it wrong. It’s infuriating to me.
It sucks she’s at it again. I’m sorry that you had to deal with that. Thanks for posting about this.
Oh, HB. I’m so sorry that we both still have to go through this sh*t. I was born and raised in Memphis and for some reason I’m still here. I still get the “you speak so well” comment. I also have had several supervisors asks me why I feel the need to be “so educated” as if I should just be happy with where I am since noone else who looks like me seems to want more. Sometimes I explain it, sometimes I tell them that my entire family is college educated and being bilingual isn’t out of the norm for a Black woman but then again sometimes I just walk away. I even have old friends that continue to tease me about using “big words”. It is disheartening sometimes. It really does “make me wanna holler and throw up both my hands”.
President Obama gives me hope that someday one of my people — godless heathens — might be elected president. We’re even more objectionable to the masses than gays.
What happened to Shirley Sherrod didn’t happen because the administration isn’t black enough. I believe it happened because the administration is feeling much the same way you did at that fundraiser — far too conscious of what bears no relevance to your potential or your performance.
That’s super crappy that you feel that way. Not cool at all. It must be exhausting when you run up against examples all the time of this kind of behavior–not just Maureen Dowd’s.
At least know you are a fabulous woman that’s setting a great example for black, brown, white, and whatever other color women out there. I personally thank you for being a smart woman working in politics. We need you.
This weblog is being featured on Five Star Friday! http://www.schmutzie.com/fivestarfriday/2010/7/30/five-star-fridays-114th-edition-is-brought-to-you-by-e-m-for.html
well-said.
NAILED IT.
I certainly take Dowd with a big grain of salt, but my first response to her column was that it was wrong for the White House to push out Sherrod without further investigating what Beck was doing, and I really had to wonder why? I’m sure it has more to do with being afraid of FOX News than race or anything else, but he has clearly surrounded himself with a bunch of inside the beltway white guys. That can’t be good for anyone — even us white folk.
One Trackback
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Bryan Thomas, Heather B.. Heather B. said: Not Enough http://ow.ly/2gl1r (I've been bummed out all day, you guys) [...]